Thanksgiving Feast: The Strangest Twists on Classic Thanksgiving Foods
Tradition has long dictated what belongs on the Thanksgiving table. While debates may rage on classic versus cornbread stuffing or canned cranberry sauce versus homemade, most of these foods remain within the bounds of “normal.” Some cooks have decided that “normal” should be pushed to the limits and beyond. Some of these twists are both […]
SWAN
Tradition has long dictated what belongs on the Thanksgiving table. While debates may rage on classic versus cornbread stuffing or canned cranberry sauce versus homemade, most of these foods remain within the bounds of “normal.”
Some cooks have decided that “normal” should be pushed to the limits and beyond. Some of these twists are both creative and appetizing sounding. Others are…unique.
Mid-Century Twists

At the beginning of World War II, Thanksgiving had been officially signed into law as being permanently on the fourth Thursday of November. Post World War II, mid-century American cooks seemed to decide that with the holiday signed into law, they could proceed to get creative with the menu.
Cooks of the era were unhealthily obsessed with Jell-O. Instead of, “Would you like fries with that?” cooks seem to ask, “Can I Jell-O that?” While gelatin salads graced many a Thanksgiving table–often combined with mayonnaise, vegetables, or fruit–cooks didn’t stop there. Instead, they decided that Jell-O could also solve the problem of what to do with leftovers. Namely, pack everything from the turkey to the vegetables into unflavored gelatin or a layered cranberry salad. Or, if one just couldn’t wait for leftovers to break out the Jell-O, one could just forgo the turkey centerpiece on the table for cold turkey in Jell-O served alongside the usual sides.
Sides also weren’t safe from the onslaught of creative cooks. One salad combined pineapple, sharp cheddar, and ritz crackers into a casserole. The combination of fruit and cheese didn’t end there and numerous salads and sides combined the two. Canned soups had made their debut decades earlier, but by the mid-century, cooks had started adding them to any and all casseroles. While green bean casserole attained staying power on the Thanksgiving table, when was the last time anyone rinsed sauerkraut and combined it with cream of mushroom soup, celery, and cracker crumbs? Many of the sides were created to use convenience foods.
Some mid-century ads just skipped the cooking and advocated for Banquet frozen turkey dinners.
Hostesses looking for a drink to serve were encouraged by Dr. Pepper to serve hot Dr. Pepper with slices of lemon in the bottom. The ad campaign was an attempt by the company to help with the low soft drink sales in winter.
For dessert, cooks also embraced convenience foods and soda pop. Dr. Pepper was boiled down to flavor fudge or (along with a variety of other soda pop flavors) added to cakes. Potato chips also made their way into desserts and appeared in pies in place of pecans, were ground up and added to cakes, and also replaced flour in coffee cake streusel for extra crunch.
Lest we think we have outgrown our strange obsession with twisting classic Thanksgiving foods, let’s move on.
Modern Twists

Some cooks now make Thanksgiving sushi. By rolling up staples of the usual Thanksgiving table star into a rice roll and adding cranberry to the wasabi, this twist creates a different option for adventurous eaters. Other world foods have also combined with the Thanksgiving staples to create Thanksgiving-world-food fusions. Pierogis are stuffed with turkey and stuffing and topped with gravy. Samosas also package Thanksgiving foods inside.
Pizza also makes its way onto the list. Traditional Thanksgiving flavors are added to a pizza crust along with an egg for a unique Thanksgiving pizza. Of course, Thanksgiving sandwiches are also popular with cream cheese, stuffing, cranberry sauce, and turkey shoved between slabs of bread.
Those looking for drinks also have some options. One restaurant infuses bourbon with butternut squash for a Thanksgiving-inspired drink. If you’re looking for something everyone at the table can enjoy there is the option to purchase a tofurkey and gravy soda pop.
Dessert has also been altered into more creative options. Pumpkin doughnuts filled with cranberry filling are one option that combines Hannukah and Thanksgiving flavors into one dish. Other global twists include Japanese egg rolls stuffed with pumpkin and topped with caramel or pumpkin pie fortune cookies.
While these more modern recipes are more intended as dishes inspired by Thanksgiving rather than attempts to alter the traditional Thanksgiving table, one thing remains the same. Cooks love to create.
So what’s your opinion? Are you rushing to include any of these ideas on your Thanksgiving table, or do you prefer the comfort of tradition?
While we can’t tell you if any of these recipes are yuck or yum, Swan Software Solutions does offer reliable, scalable, and affordable technology services to our clients. Schedule a free assessment to find out more.
Have a wonderful Thanksgiving!